Tennessee Sales Tax Law Does Not Discriminate Against Satellite Television Providers
- Sales Tax News
- Mar 6, 2015 | Gail Cole
DIRECTV, Inc, and EchoStar Satellite Corporation (now DISH Network L.L.C.) took the Tennessee Commissioner of Revenue to Court over a sales tax law that it contends “unconstitutionally discriminates against satellite television providers.” The trial court ruled in favor of the satellite television providers. The Tennessee Court of Appeals at Nashville did not.
As explained in the Court of Appeals opinion, Tennessee law “taxes the entire subscription fee billed to satellite customers while the first $15 of the subscription fee billed to cable customers is exempt.”
In its opinion, the court delves into the challenges to disparate taxation of satellite and cable providers, the history of taxation of satellite and cable providers by Tennessee, and the distinction between satellite and cable providers. Ultimately, it concludes that “satellite providers and cable providers are not substantially similar entities for purposes of the Commerce Clause.” As a result, the court reversed the trial court’s judgment in favor of DIRECTV and DISH. Read the full opinion for additional details.
Unless the decision of the Court of Appeals is challenged, the Tennessee Department of Revenue will expect satellite television providers to remit sales tax on the first $15 of customer subscription fees.
Automated sales tax Software-as-a-Service helps businesses simplify sales tax management and increase compliance in Tennessee and other states. Learn how it works.