VATLive > Blog > European News > UK VAT fines if ‘should have known’ of fraud - Avalara

UK VAT fines if ‘should have known’ of fraud

UK VAT fines if ‘should have known’ of fraud

The UK’s HMRC has launched a consultation on VAT fraud, which includes introducing potential fines on companies that ‘knew or should have known their transactions were connected with fraud’.

Arguably, EU case law points to parties in a fraudulent transaction who merely knew or should have identified the fraud (didn’t instigate or benefit from the fraud) losing the right to deduct any VAT incurred. See Axel Kittel v Belgian State. This is termed the ‘knowledge principle’.

An example test for the knowledge principle is: could there be no other reasonable explanation for a low sales price other than VAT being fraudulently excluded? This HMRC consultation covers the option to issue a fine covering this principle.  If implemented, we can explain a number of test case challenging this as overreach by HMRC.

The consultation will consider the nature of any penalties, can company Directors be made liable and a policy of naming and shaming offenders.


The UK estimated that is loses £13.5billion per annum in its VAT Gap – the difference between the expected VAT raised each year compared to actual receipts. This deficit is made up of VAT fraud, poor administrative collection policies and liquidations of companies owing VAT.

Latest British news
UK MTD pilot goes public; Oct 2019 groups & non-resident delay
October 16, 2018

HMRC announced today that it is opening the test pilot for its Making Tax Digital for VAT programme to the public.  However, HMRC also announced...
Avalara MTD Filer FREE tool for HMRC’s MTD
October 4, 2018

From 1 April 2019, more than 2 million VAT-registered businesses will be required to digitize their accounting and VAT filing for the new HMRC Making...
UK Making Tax Digital pilot goes public
September 20, 2018

The UK’s HRMC has confirmed the next-stage plans for its Making Tax Digital (MTD) for VAT pilot. The pilot is aimed at helping develop filing...

VP Global Indirect Tax
Richard Asquith
VP Global Indirect Tax Richard Asquith
Richard Asquith is VP Global Indirect Tax at Avalara, helping businesses understand their compliance obligations as they grow globally. He is part of the European leadership team which this year won International Tax Review's Tax Technology Firm of the Year. Richard qualified as an accountant with KPMG in the UK, and went on to work in Hungary, Russia and France with EY.